Weather.co
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos
75 °f
New York
75 ° Mon
74 ° Tue
73 ° Wed
75 ° Thu
SUBSCRIBE
Weather.co
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Weather.co
No Result
View All Result
Home Climate Change

Florida Judge Asked to Recognize the Legal Rights of Five Waterways Outside Orlando

April 27, 2022
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0 0
A A
0

In the first U.S. enforcement action related to a burgeoning “rights of nature” movement, which holds that rivers, mountains and forests have legal rights, an attorney acting on behalf of two lakes, two streams and a marsh outside Orlando argued before a Florida judge on Tuesday that the waterways’ lawsuit against a developer is legally valid and belongs in state court.

Wilde Cypress Branch, Boggy Branch, Crosby Island Marsh, Lake Hart and Lake Mary, along with their co-plaintiff, Chuck O’Neal, filed the lawsuit last year based on a 2020 rights of nature amendment to Orange County’s Charter, the county’s mini constitution. 

That amendment, approved by 89 percent of voters, granted waterways in the county the right to “exist, flow, to be protected against pollution and to maintain a healthy ecosystem.” 

The case concerns a permit Florida Department of Environmental Protection issued to Beachline South residential, the developer, to dredge, fill, and transport waterways in order to construct residential and commercial buildings. The plaintiffs, along with the waterways, claim that this activity will violate their rights. They asked the court to issue an order stopping the development.

Beachline South Residential and Florida’s DEP filed a motion to dismiss the case, arguing, among other things, that state legislation preempts the Orange County Charter amendment, effectively rendering the waterways’ rights null. They argue that the dispute regarding the validity of the fill permit and dredge is an administrative matter that should instead be heard in state court.

O’Neal, the plaintiff and environmentalist who ran the charter change campaign in Orange County two years ago, said he hoped the case might become a model for the rest of the world and that he was pleased that the rights of nature were having their day in court. 

Excessive pollution and nutrient runoff causing algae blooms “aren’t just Florida problems, they are world problems,” he said. “People around the world will watch what is happening in Florida and it will resonate with them.”

The battle over who gets a say in how the natural environment is protected—whether at the state or local level—is at the heart of the rights of nature movement in the United States. This movement seeks legal rights for ecosystems like rivers or forests and raises the level of protection provided to the environment than standard environmental protection laws. 

More than 30 localities in the United States have passed rights of nature laws, including in Ohio, Colorado and Pennsylvania. Florida’s Republican Governor. Ron DeSantis is a rising star in Florida. Other Florida cities like Titusville, Venice, Fort Myers, Naples are in varying stages of developing their own rights of nature ordinances, following Orange County’s example. 

However, the U.S. courts have never upheld a rights law of nature. There are still dozens of laws on the books that are awaiting litigation. The U.S. laws face unique challenges, mainly because they are mostly local ordinances. This is due to legal precedent that subordinates local laws and lawsuits from state legislation. The current case involving Orange County’s charter change could be the most consequential legal moment to date for the rights of nature movement in the U.S. legal system. 

Globally, rights of nature provisions have been put in place through legislation, judicial rulings and constitutional amendments in countries that include Canada, Mexico, Colombia, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Bolivia, India, New Zealand, Uganda and Ecuador, where the country’s high court recently upheld a constitutional provision granting the rights of nature and ruled that a mining company threatened the legal rights of the Los Cedros protected area.  

The U.S. rights of nature movement is popular with communities frustrated by the state and federal governments’ inability to adequately protect the environment. 

In Florida, the problem is particularly acute, with a confluence of pollution from agriculture, industrial facilities, sewage systems and urban runoff causing toxic algae blooms that kill off wildlife and affect the state’s tourism industry. 

During his argument before the court, Steve Meyers, the attorney for the waterways and O’Neal, said that the state of Florida has a duty under the state constitution to adequately protect Florida’s waters, but that the government’s existing laws and regulations have failed. 

“If you walk outside the courtroom, you can see our lakes and rivers are filthy,” he said. “It is clear that the laws are not adequate.”

Keep Environmental Journalism Alive

ICN provides award-winning coverage of climate free of charge and without advertising. To keep going, we rely on donations by readers like you.

Donate Now

Meyers also argued that Florida DEP’s issuance of the dredge and fill permit was invalid because it was based on an improper delegation of authority from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to Florida’s DEP under the federal Clean Water Act. 

This legislation generally prohibits the pollution of waterways, unless otherwise allowed. A federal law requires that a permit-granting agency consider issues such as the effects on wildlife and local laws before granting a permit for polluting. 

In Florida, Meyers argued, the state doesn’t have adequate criteria in place requiring the DEP to consider issues like effects on wildlife and local laws before the agency makes permitting decisions. 

“Everyone in the United States has the benefit of the federal clean water act except for people in Florida,” he said. “It is outrageous.” 

Meyers also argued that the waterways’ lawsuit belongs in state court rather than before Florida’s DEP because the case involves interpretation of the county charter amendment and state law.

The state law at issue prohibits local governments from recognizing or granting legal rights to the natural environment and was supported by Florida’s Farm Bureau Federation. The law was enacted after the proposed rights of waterways amendment was put on Orange County’s 2020 ballot, but before the voting took place. 

Attorneys for Beachline South Residential and Florida’s DEP argued, among other things, that the waterways’ challenge to the dredge and fill permit should be made before Florida’s DEP rather than in state court, that state law rightfully preempts the Orange County Charter amendment and that the state legislature is empowered to determine what environmental laws are adequate to protect waterways as opposed to local governments. 

Judge Paetra T. Brownlee did not issue a decision at the hearing and gave the parties 35 days to submit proposed orders on how the court should rule on the defendants’ motion to dismiss. 

Katie Surma

Reporter, Pittsburgh

Katie Surma, a reporter for Inside Climate News, focuses on international environmental law. Prior to joining ICN, Surma was a lawyer who specialized in commercial litigation. She has also written for a variety of publications, and her stories have appeared in The Washington Post, USA Today and Chicago Tribune, Seattle Times, and The Associated Press. Katie has a master’s degree in investigative journalism from Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, an LLM in international rule of law and security from ASU’s Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law, a J.D. Duquesne University. She was also a History of Art and Architecture major at University of Pittsburgh. Katie lives in Pittsburgh with Jim Crowell.

Source: Inside Climate News

ShareTweetShareShareShareSend

Related Posts

Climate Change

Mexican Drought Spurs a South Texas Water Crisis

August 15, 2022
Climate Change

After finally passing a climate bill, US calls on others to act

August 15, 2022
Climate Change

Out in the Fields, Contemplating Humanity and a Parched Almond Farm

August 15, 2022
Climate Change

Outnumbered: In Rural Ohio, Two Supporters of Solar Power Step Into a Roomful of Opposition

August 14, 2022
Climate Change

Warming Trends: Sports and Climate Change in Texas, a Community Housing Project Named after Rachel Carson and an E-Bike Conversion Kit for Your Bicycle

August 13, 2022
Climate Change

China-US climate “oasis” turns to desert – Climate Weekly

August 12, 2022
London, GB
1:29 am, Aug 16
68°F
L: 62° H: 70°
Feels like 67.37 °F overcast clouds
Wind gusts: 7 mph
UV Index: 0
Precipitation: 0 inch
Visibility: 10 km
Sunrise: 5:47 am
Sunset: 8:22 pm
Humidity 72 %
Pressure1005 mb
Wind 7 mph

Recommended Stories

Macy’s returns to prepandemic sales levels and faces a new challenge: inflation

February 22, 2022

‘I’ve Never Seen a Flood Like This’: Bangladesh Reels from Heavy Rains

June 24, 2022

3 Monster Storms Coming! Hurricane Winds! Major Power Outages! – Video

January 20, 2022

Popular Stories

  • An end date to higher fertilizer prices is unknown, AFBF economists say

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • How High Oil Prices Threaten a California Plastic Container Business

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Skyrocketing fertilizer prices gouge farmer profits; groups blame consolidation

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ukraine monitors price increases for goods, planting challenges as war continues

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • A Hotter World

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Weather.co

Weather.co, is a dedicated weather news website, we provide the latest news about weather and climate change from all around the world.

LEARN MORE »

Recent Posts

  • Mexican Drought Spurs a South Texas Water Crisis
  • After finally passing a climate bill, US calls on others to act
  • Out in the Fields, Contemplating Humanity and a Parched Almond Farm

Sections

  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Coronavirus
  • Farming
  • News
  • Videos

The Latest Weather News From All Around The World

Be the first to know latest important news & events directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

© 2021 Weather.co - All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos

© 2021 Weather.co - All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
DON’T MISS OUT!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Be the first to get latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox.
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.
close-link
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.