Weather.co
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos
77 °f
New York
80 ° Fri
79 ° Sat
77 ° Sun
76 ° Mon
SUBSCRIBE
Weather.co
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Weather.co
No Result
View All Result
Home Climate Change

In San Francisco’s Most Polluted Neighborhood, the Polluters Operate Without Proper Permits, Reports Say

December 31, 2021
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0 0
A A
0

Raymond Tompkins thinks the high efficiency air filters in his old, gold Mercedes are among the car’s best features. They trap dust and tiny pollution particles, and they’re fitted with activated charcoal to help remove odors—an invaluable function for a longtime resident of San Francisco’s most polluted neighborhood. 

“You know, I’m supposed to be dead,” Tompkins, 72, said. “Most Black men don’t live this long, here in Bayview. I’ve been going to a funeral every month.”

Bayview-Hunters Point is a predominantly low-income, minority neighborhood in the southeastern corner of the city. It means that you have to ignore the dust from the hills of asphalt and sand piled up in industrial yards. 

For decades, a confluence of polluting factors has dominated the four-square-mile neighborhood. A state environmental analysis found that the Bayview area had the highest cumulative pollution burden in the entire city. 

Local advocates suggested that state and local agencies should actively work to reduce pollution in Bayview. Instead, they have allowed polluting facilities to continue to operate in Bayview without final pollution permits.

On Bayview’s Piers 92 and 94, which border San Francisco Bay, a concrete plant and two sand offloading facilities have operated for years without final pollution permits from the Bay Area Air Quality Management District, according to reports released in 2017 and 2020 by the Environmental Justice Law Clinic at Golden Gate University’s School of Law. CEMEX Construction Materials owns the concrete plant, while Hanson Aggregates Mid Pacific sold the sand facilities to Martin Materials in November.

The violations were first reported to the air district in 2017. However, enforcement actions have been delayed and most plants are allowed to continue operating. They claim that they have been working with facilities on draft permits.

These permits were issued to the facility in draft form four years ago, after which they continue to be used. 

“Under the Clean Air Act, if you don’t have a permit, you can’t pollute,” said Lucas Williams, an associate law professor at Golden Gate University and a staff attorney at the law clinic. The Clean Air Act is the primary federal law that regulates air quality. It was established in 1963. To be able to pollute, polluting facilities must obtain permits from local agencies. 

The air district requires polluting facilities to submit completed permit applications within 90 days of being notified by the air district of a violation, or else they will be prevented from operating—a rule that the air district fails to enforce, the report said. 

Instead, the district allows for “an extended period of back-and-forth” with the permit applicant when it fails to submit sufficient information, the report said. This long-standing practice leads to permits that remain pending for years while polluting facilities continue to operate.

Ralph Borrmann, the air district’s public information officer, said in an email that the agency has delayed moving the permits forward because “additional information is still needed to better understand the impacts to the neighborhood.” The air district will conduct an environmental review of the facilities to learn more, as required by the 1970 California Environmental Quality Act, he said. 

“These projects have taken the Air District more time to assess than we would have liked,” Borrman said. “As the Air District has gone through this process, rules, policies and priorities have changed, which led to some delay.”

He added that the air district “attempts to collect penalties in amounts that deter future violations.” 

The air district filed a complaint against another concrete plant for violating its permit. They sought a $75,000 penalty from Central Concrete Supply. Central Concrete settled the case for $9,000.  Recology, a recycling company that was operating a concrete crushing operation while it waited for a permit in 2016, closed the division after receiving a violation notice in 2021. 

The Bay Area Air District regulates stationary sources for air pollution in the nine Bay Area County counties. The air district issues permits to limit the amount of concrete or sand that can be processed in a certain time frame. The air district also regulates the moisture content of processed material—material that exceeds 5 percent moisture content is exempt from permitting requirements.

However, the CEMEX concrete plant  “regularly” exceeded the amount of throughput without authorization from the air district, processing as much as five times more than its permit limit of 60,000 tons, according to the law clinic reports. 

Since 2001, Hanson Sand and Material Handling Facilities on Piers 9 and 94 have been in operation without permits. Pier 94 was originally exempted, but the exemption was revoked when the district discovered that its stockpiles had a moisture level below 5 percent. 

Martin Marietta and CEMEX didn’t immediately respond to our requests for comment.

Residents are concerned about the health effects of these facilities operating so close to their homes and within a few thousand feet of an emergency Covid-19 shelter. 

Concrete batch plants, such as those on Piers 92 or 94, emit fine particulate matters known as PM2.5 or PM10. These are particles that measure 2.5 to 10 microns in diameter. These particulates can stay in the atmosphere for several weeks and reduce visibility. They can also be easily inhaled, which can cause lung damage, including asthma, heart attack, and premature death. 

According to a 2016 study by the San Francisco Health Improvement Partnership, Bayview has the highest rates of asthma-related hospitalizations and emergency room visits in the city. 

Williams, the staff attorney at the law clinic, stated that facilities without valid permits should be closed down in the interim rather than being fined. Lax enforcement on the part of the air district is indicative of a more widespread pattern and practice of not protecting the Bay Area’s disadvantaged communities, he said. 

“The bottom line is that the district should not be putting more polluting facilities where there are already a ton of polluting facilities,” Williams said.

The air district is not able to close these facilities. They would need to get a court order or approval from a hearing board, Simrun Dhoot, a senior engineer in air quality at the district, told Inside Climate News. 

It’s within the air district’s discretion whether or not to bring an enforcement action against a violator, said Dave Owen, an environmental law professor at the University of California’s Hastings College of Law in San Francisco. In this instance, the air district decided that working with the facility on a permit was a better option than closing down the facility.  

Keep Environmental Journalism Alive

ICN provides award-winning coverage of climate free of charge and without advertising. To keep going, we rely on donations by readers like you.

Donate Now

You will be redirected to ICN’s donation partner.

But while the air district can’t unilaterally make a decision to shut down operations, it could “at least initiate enforcement action, and the threat of a shutdown order would probably lead the facilities to take permitting and pollution control more seriously,” Owen said.

“I think it’s an issue,” he added. “For industrial-scale emitters to operate for years under draft permits and in an overburdened community isn’t how things are supposed to work.”

Elena Shao

Reporter, San Francisco

Elena Shao is an Inside Climate News fellow reporting on environmental justice. She’s based in the San Francisco Bay Area and is a graduate student in Stanford University’s journalism program. You can also find her work at CalMatters. The San Francisco Chronicle and The Wall Street Journal.

Source: Inside Climate News

ShareTweetShareShareShareSend

Related Posts

Climate Change

Twitter diplomacy and Brazil’s climate election – Climate Weekly

August 19, 2022
Climate Change

The New US Climate Law Will Reduce Carbon Emissions and Make Electricity Less Expensive, Economists Say

August 19, 2022
Climate Change

Brazil’s climate election: Lula and Bolsonaro vie over deforestation

August 18, 2022
Climate Change

A Natural Ecology Lab Along the Delaware River in the First State to Require K-12 Climate Education

August 18, 2022
Climate Change

Laredo Confronts Drought and Water Shortage Without a Wealth of Options

August 18, 2022
Climate Change

Study: Pennsylvania Children Who Live Near Fracking Wells Have Higher Leukemia Risk

August 17, 2022
London, GB
2:59 pm, Aug 19
76°F
L: 71° H: 79°
Feels like 75.06 °F broken clouds
Wind gusts: 9 mph
UV Index: 0
Precipitation: 0 inch
Visibility: 10 km
Sunrise: 5:52 am
Sunset: 8:16 pm
Humidity 42 %
Pressure1014 mb
Wind 9 mph

Recommended Stories

Island states back Vanuatu’s quest for climate justice at the UN

May 24, 2022

The Current Rate of Ocean Warming Could Bring the Greatest Extinction of Sealife in 250 Million Years

April 28, 2022

Did a Meteor Explode Over Pittsburgh?

January 3, 2022

Popular Stories

  • An end date to higher fertilizer prices is unknown, AFBF economists say

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • How High Oil Prices Threaten a California Plastic Container Business

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Skyrocketing fertilizer prices gouge farmer profits; groups blame consolidation

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ukraine monitors price increases for goods, planting challenges as war continues

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • A Hotter World

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Weather.co

Weather.co, is a dedicated weather news website, we provide the latest news about weather and climate change from all around the world.

LEARN MORE »

Recent Posts

  • Twitter diplomacy and Brazil’s climate election – Climate Weekly
  • The New US Climate Law Will Reduce Carbon Emissions and Make Electricity Less Expensive, Economists Say
  • Brazil’s climate election: Lula and Bolsonaro vie over deforestation

Sections

  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Coronavirus
  • Farming
  • News
  • Videos

The Latest Weather News From All Around The World

Be the first to know latest important news & events directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

© 2021 Weather.co - All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Forecast
  • Weather News
  • Analysis
  • Climate Change
  • Videos

© 2021 Weather.co - All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
DON’T MISS OUT!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Be the first to get latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox.
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.
close-link
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.